The Phonograph – Edison’s Greatest Invention? Essay

  1. The Phonograph vs. the Incandescent Light Bulb

The incandescent visible radiation bulb is by and large considered to be Edison’s greatest innovation. However. Edison did non truly ‘invent’ the light bulb but instead improved upon the already bing versions to do them operable for place usage. Before Edison. many people had already worked on and even reasonably succeeded in developing illuming equipment based on electricity ( about. com 2006 ) .

Hire a custom writer who has experience.
It's time for you to submit amazing papers!

order now

Edison’s find of the efficaciousness of the carbonized fibril. and a few other attendant conditions. in his hunt to bring forth a dependable and longer-lasting beginning of visible radiation are no uncertainty of enormous significance — but they are more in the nature of invention than original innovation. Today we may outdo retrieve Edison as an discoverer of electric lighting. since visible radiation has got a more powerful symbolic value than possibly anything else in our lives. but on legion histories the record player could be regarded as the greatest innovation of Edison’s life.

It was the innovation of record player in 1877 that first catapulted Edison into the kingdom of international celebrity. he became a family name about overnight. It was a colossal innovation. and in many ways his first great. Although Edison already had many achievements to his recognition. particularly in the Fieldss of telegraphy and telephone. and had already founded the first modern research research lab. the record player represents the major discovery in the immature Edison’s life and calling. Furthermore. it evolved from uniting Edison’s before work on telegraph and the telephone. and as such Markss the fruition of over a decennary of relentless nisus after innovation and find in communications engineering.

The innovation of the visible radiation bulb which was to come two old ages subsequently. and its unbounded impact on mundane lives of people everyplace. merely consolidated the repute of Edison’s mastermind that had already been established by the widely acclaimed innovation of the record player. It may be interesting to compare and contrast the two greatest innovations of Edison. the record player and the incandescent visible radiation bulb. to the two greatest finds of Einstein. the particular theory of relativity and the general theory of relativity. Einstein’s foremost major achievement. the preparation of particular relativity in 1905. did non convey him much celebrity. although it was in it that he framed the now legendary equation of E = MC2.

Even the most of import accomplishment of his life. the preparation of the general relativity in 1915. for which he was to have the Nobel award. failed to convey him much acclamation — until a documentation for it emerged from astronomical observations conducted in 1919. at which point. Einstein immediately became a phenomenal famous person world-wide. Sing his work. Einstein himself said the first theory of particular relativity could hold been discovered by anyone else even if non him. as it was merely a apogee of decennaries of work by many other theoretical physicists. but the theory of general relativity genuinely had many alone penetrations.

Similarly many research workers had been working to come up with a feasible electric beginning of visible radiation during Edison’s clip. there was an paramount necessity for cheaper and efficient signifier of visible radiation in the modern civilised society ; person or other was bound to hold perfected the visible radiation bulb even if Edison were nowhere in the image. Whereas the record player bears the cast of Edison’s mastermind and imaginativeness in a most alone manner. . The record player was really much of a freshness than a necessity during Edison’s clip. It was in fact so unexpected by the populace at that clip as to hold seemed about charming ( Wikipedia 2006 ) .

It is really likely that if Edison did non come up with it. the innovation of record player could hold even been delayed by two or three decennaries. Therefore. the record player is sometimes considered to be the greatest innovation of Edison’s life. even superior to his iconic visible radiation bulb. However. as in the instance of Einstein. it is hard to clearly asseverate which achievement is superior to which of the large two. Each was radical. and held immense deductions to the hereafter of scientific discipline and engineering in its ain manner. If the incandescent visible radiation bulb was a superb effort of human inventiveness. the record player was no less a resounding success.

  1. The Invention of the Phonograph

Notwithstanding all the esthesis it created. Edison’s record player was basically a really simple mechanism. “The record player was a wonder that amazed both the scientific and proficient community and the public because of its arrant simpleness. ” says Paul Israel in his life ‘Edison: A Life of Invention’ .

It was fundamentally a metal cylinder wrapped around with Sn foil. and may remind us of the Henry David Thoreau’s axiom: simpleness of life and lift of intent. When noticing about Edison’s innovation. Alexander Graham Bell honestly admitted that he felt it amazing that such a simple find could hold eluded him. However. it was Edison’s background in working with telephones. every bit good as the telegraph. that gave him advantage over Graham Bell who lacked anchoring in the topic of telegraphy ( Israel 2000 ) .

As Professor Alfred Mayer justly predicted upon witnessing a presentation of the speaking machine: possessing immense capablenesss. the device had far-reaching deductions for scientific discipline and engineering. However. even Edison did non set out to make a record player as it subsequently turned out to be.

Edison originally conceived the record player simply as a sort of replying machine. in order to enter telephone messages so that they could be played back and transcribed. Pulling analogues between the telephone and the telegraph. Edison wondered why should it non be possible to enter telephone messages. and even produce written records out of them. Edison had been working on a machine that would publish telegraphic messages by doing indentures on paper tape when he began dallying with the impression of entering telephone messages in a similar mode.

Edison conducted some preliminary experiments in July of 1877 with a “diaphragm holding an stamping point and held against paper traveling quickly. ” The consequences rapidly gave him assurance that it was so possible to enter human voice absolutely ( ibid. p. 144 ) . However during the following several months he was excessively preoccupied with his work on the telephone to decently concentrate on the construct of record player.

In November that twelvemonth. Edison used a piece of tin foil wrapped around a big. grooved cylinder. alternatively of paraffined paper for a recording surface. The consequences dramatically improved. When a individual expressed words into a mouthpiece. the sound quivers were indented onto the cylinder by the recording acerate leaf. The machine could play back the words with impressive fidelity. though in low sound quality. Soon the new cylinder record player was on its manner to the office of Scientific American in New York.

  1. The Development and Impact of the Phonograph

By the New Year. Edison had improved his appliance sufficiency to be able to do public presentations and attract New York journalists. Over the following few months. the promotion for the record player stirred up a regular whirlpool in the media capital of the United States. But while Edison got busy invariably giving interviews and talking to the newsmans. he did non pretermit to set attempts to recognize the commercial potency of the record player. He secured major support from Bell telephone involvements really early on.

In late January of 1878. Bell involvements sanctioned $ 10. 000 for Edison’s experiments and created the Edison Speaking Phonograph Company to market the new innovation. To advance and market both his telephone and record player in Europe. Edison struck trades with a Hungarian-born European enterpriser Theordore Puskas ( ibid. p. 148 ) .

In April of 1878. Edison was invited by the President of the National Academy of Sciences. Washington D. C. . to show his innovation before the Academy. Edison was going widely recognized as a most clever discoverer. by the scientific community and laypersons likewise. In Washington. Edison besides got an chance to exhibit the record player to the President Rutherford B. Hayes and the members of Congress. Soon. Edison’s celebrity began distributing all over the state. every bit good as across the Atlantic ( ibid. p. 153 ) .

Though the original record player was devised as a concern machine. over the class of the following decennary. Edison’s landmark innovation led him into the amusement industry.

In retrospective. Edison made a comment subsequently in his life to the consequence that they had an interesting and setup in their custodies but by and large had non many thoughts as to its broad scope of practical possibilities ( ibid. p. 277 ) . Though the record player was discovered in a unusually short clip. as if by serendipity. its development in both in the Fieldss of concern and amusement took old ages if non decennaries. In the subsequent old ages. many discoverers including Alexander Graham Bell worked on honing the record player each in his ain manner. besides Edison himself.

The record player kept altering its face. the cylinder record player going a disc record player for illustration. and at the same clip. it changed the face of communications and amusement industry. Edison’s concern in record player flourished good. and finally his dream of holding a record player in every American place became a close world.


Approximately. com. ( 2006 ) .The Inventions of Thomas Edison: History of Phonograph – Lightbulb –

Gesture Pictures.Retrieved September 14. 2006 from

hypertext transfer protocol: //inventors. about. com/library/inventors/bledison. htm

Israel. Paul. ( 2000 ) .Edison: A Life of Invention.Hoboken. New jersey: John Wiley and Sons

Wikipedia. ( 2006 ) .Thomas Edison. Retrieved September 14. 2006 from

hypertext transfer protocol: //en. wikipedia. org/wiki/Thomas_Edison